Filippo Tenerelli
was born on November 4th, 1945 in Italy. I have been
unable to find the name of his father, but his mother’s name was
Caterina. Filippo lived with his parents in Italy until moving to the
United States in 1959. He did not have any history or mental illness
or arrests. There is not much known about Filippo in general, though
significant points of interest are that he spoke with an Italian
accent, and seemed to have an interest in motorcycles, having driven
one at some point.
The Tenerelli’s
settled in the Los Angeles area, with documentation showing that
Filippo at least lived in Culver City in 1969.
In 1964, Filippo got
into a motorcycle accident. He was sent to the Washington Hospital in
Culver City and was operated on and had X-Rays. I am assuming that he
was for the most part okay after this incident.
On September 29th,
1969, Filippo left his parents’ house from Culver City, all the way
to Father Crowley Point in Death Valley, which is in Inyo county.
According to google maps, this would be about a 4 hour drive.
Now as the story
goes, Filippo was going to allegedly drive of the cliff and kill
himself, though when this was supposed to have happened, the car got
stuck. For some reason, Filippo had a pickax and shovel in his car,
took them out, and used them to move the car. Infuriated, he pushed
the car over the edge. Apparently, the car fell 400 feet and Filippo
went down to the bottom of the canyon to retrieve some of his
belongings, while doing so, he cut his hand and blood splattered on
the ceiling.
Afterwards, it is
unknown where he spent his time next, but apparently on the night of
September 30th, Filippo ended up in Bishop, which is 100
miles away, and an hour and a half drive. I am quite suspicious how
he ended up there, unless he miraculously got picked up hitch hiking.
Once Filippo got to Bishop, he checked into the Sportsman Lodge
motel, paying 156 dollars in advance to stay until November 3rd.
Interestingly, that would be long enough to be before his birthday.
On October 1st,
Filippo went to the sporting goods store and bought a 20 gauge
shotgun, ammo, and cleaning kit. He also went to another store and
bought two fifths of whiskey, 2 pairs of underwear, a safety razor,
and an issue of Playboy. I am unsure what size the underwear was, and
if it would have been the right size to fit him.
|
An old picture from the motel
|
The last person to
have seen Filippo alive was the motel owner, Bee Greer. He had come
out of his room because he had heard the sirens of fire engines. Bee
told Filippo that the fire department were doing a controlled
demolition of a building that was across from them to which he
watched awhile then went back to his room.
The next morning, a
maid tried to get into his room but was unable to. They found that it
had been barricaded, and later on in the day, Bee Greer’s husband
and son had to push it in. When they did, they found Filippo on the
floor dead, a gunshot wound to the back of the head.
Apparently Filippo
had blocked the door with a chair, and put the shotgun to his mouth,
pulling the trigger with his toe. His head lay on two Turkish bath
towels, which the police report postulated may have been to soak up
the blood. A bed pillow was over his head to muffle the sound of the
gunshot. Filippo’s body was found with his pubic hair shaved, and
some of it between the pages of the Playboy magazine that he had
bought. The two bottles of whiskey that he had bought were still in
the room, one empty and the other only a third full. There was a
slash on his wrist from an attempt at committing suicide that way.
In the end, his
death was considered a suicide.
|
A scan of the picture that the coroner drew
|
In the 51 years
since, many people who have heard of this case do not consider it to
be a suicide. The details of the case do not add up, and many believe
it to be murder. I didn’t come across this case until I started
reading Tom O’Neill’s book, ‘Chaos’
which delves more into Manson type things. O’Neill believes that
Tenerelli was murdered by the Manson family. Admittedly, there are
many things that are unexplained and off about Tenerelli’s case.
First
is his blood alcohol level. At the time of death, Filippo’s BAC was
only 0.03%. Barely even intoxicated. And yet, one of the bottles of
alcohol was completely empty, and the other almost there. This
definitely implies that someone had to have been there at some point
visiting him, drinking together.
In
O’Neill’s book, he stated that he had asked about the windows,
and the mayor of the town stated that the motel’s windows were too
small to fit anyone in or out of. The mayor also wrongly stated that
the motel had been torn down years ago. In reality, a ranch bought
the building, O’Neill saw it in person, and the windows were indeed
big enough for someone to crawl in and out of, even two people.
Now,
when Tenerelli died, he was listed as a John Doe, despite having
signed in at the front desk. The owner of the motel, Bee Greer,
stated that should never have signed in anyone to stay if they didnt
have either a drivers license or an ID, and she stated that Tenerelli
had an ID. Interestingly, the person that signed in at the front desk
looked just enough like Tenerelli to have apparently passed for him
on the ID, though there has never been any confirmation of what
Tenerelli looked like at the time, and what his ID looked like. Bee
Greer stated that the person she signed in did not have an accent.
The real Tenerelli had a distinct Italian accent. Either Bee’s
story is incorrect, or someone signed in for Filippo.
Filippo’s
family filed him as missing on October 3rd of that year.
On the 4th, two hunters saw the Beetle that Filippo had
pushed over the cliff, and notified police. When an officer came
around, he saw the blood on the ceiling and suspected foul play.
Filippo’s family learned of the car being in Death Valley at that
time. It wasn’t until three weeks later that the police in Bishop
identified Filippo as their John Doe. On October 30th,
1969, the Inyo Register reported that the Doe was Tenerelli. Filippo
had been identified by the x-rays from his 1964 hospital stay.
Interestingly though, the Inyo county coroner had been notified of
this within 24 hours, yet the chief of police did not tell the news
until October 28th. The Inyo County sheriff’s office,
the ones that found Fillipo’s car, wanted to know who the person
was that dumped it. Coroner Brune told them that they had identified
the body two weeks earlier.
Apparently,
the Manson Family was briefly considered as having been responsible
for Filippo’s death. There was little information to the public
that showed any links, but six months later Aaron Stovitz, who had
worked with Bugliosi on the Tate case, suggested that the Tenerelli
case may have been one of the unknown Mansion deaths.
In
O’Neill’s book, once he started snooping around the town asking
law enforcement about the Tenerelli case, people gave little, wrong,
or no information at all. The Lieutenant Chris Carter stated that the
records had been purged, with unsolved homicide cases being held
indefinitely. Meanwhile, a cop told O’Neill that they had seen the
records back in 1993. Interestingly, Debra Tate had pleaded for
Tenerelli’s case to be reopened back in 2007. In 2019, an article
on Fox News stated that the case had been re-opened more than 11
years ago (which would have been at least as far back as 2008), and
was once again closed. If what Carter said was true, of holding onto
unsolved homicide records...doesn’t that mean they consider his
case an unsolved homicide?
As
Tom O’Neill wrote about his experience, the reader is supposed to
understand that the police in this situation are very corrupt. For
some reason, newer police end up being curious about it, as Tom about
what happened, and then they clam up about talking about it ever
again. It conveys that there is information in there that we are not
allowed to know, and in the book shows that the case is extremely
suspicious. I can only take this at face value since these are Tom’s
experiences. Among these is the narrative that the police are
seemingly trying to cover something up, especially in the fight that
Bee Greer had with the police in stating whether Tenerelli had an ID
or not. Bee stated that police kept trying to talk her out of saying
that he had an ID. Later on, O’Neill found a registration form that
had Tenerelli’s name on it, but misspelled. Later on, Filippo’s
sister saw the paper and confirmed that it wasn’t his handwriting.
The
scene of Tenerelli’s death contained no forensic photographs, and
had no evidence of forensic tests used, such as finger prints or
ballistics. The surgeon that performed Filippo’s autopsy, Robert
Denton, stated that he never believed that it was suicide. The only
reason he did, was because of pressure from the coroner’s office.
Denton noted that Tenerelli’s body had looked to have been in a
fight or dragged before being shot.
When
Filippo’s car had been found, the police report stated that it
couldn’t have been there for than 2 days. The car was found on
October 5th, which if the two day note is true, then it
couldn’t have been Filippo that dumped the car. Filippo passed away
on October 1st, and found on October 2nd. In
the car, they found items that implied there could have been another
person, such as a Santa Monica bus schedule, and a meal and laundry
sheet from Brentwood Hospital, where didn’t work or stay. Back when
the two hunters first saw the car, they stated that they had seen
someone come out of it, and blood all over the car. Apparently around
the 1st of October, a highway patrolman had stopped a
beatle with hippie types, that were later identified with Danny
DeCarlo as the driver of the car. At the time, DeCarlo was in
the Death Valley area. Neither cop that investigated the abandoned
car believed that Tenerelli committed suicide.
When
the Manson Family had been arrested for their auto-theft ring,
allegedly one of the girls told an officer that she’d been involved
with Tenerelli, and he’d been with the Family in Death Valley
before his death. It is unknown who said that.
The
final important bit that O’Neill brings up about the case is shaven
pubic hair found off Tenerelli’s corpse. O’Neill makes the claim
that the pubic hair could have been used in a ‘Magic Vest’ that a
rather not so well known member of the family, Bill Vance, had. In
“Chaos”, there were just a few strand of the hair betwixt the
magazine, with it being unknown what happened to the rest. Supposedly
Vance’s vest was made of pubic hair, and one that he liked to wear.
Interestingly, though, Vance was arrested for stealing a gun
out of a car in Death Valley on October 5th, 1969, The day
the car was pulled from the ravine.
Unfortunately,
despite Filippo’s mother Caterina living to be 99 years old (and
believing that she lived that long to find out the truth about her
son), she never got to know what happened to Filippo that fateful
night.
Personally,
I have a lot of questions about this situation, and it is of course
very suspicious what happened to him. I personally do not believe
that Filippo committed suicide, since the gunshot wound was to the
back of the head, and not the front. Now if the exit wound was coming
out the back, then that would be a different story. I have a list of
questions so I guess I’ll just jot them out below.
1.
What
is the real proof that this is a suicide? What was the reason for a
suicide? Did he not leave a note?
Now
I know that not every person leaves a note behind when they committ
suicide, but it is interesting, that if this is really what that was,
he did not do so. I mean, if there was a
note of some kind, it could have made this a whole lot easier, unless
the person that was there decided to plant one.
2.
Did any of his family members experience
him acting different within the months prior to his alleged suicide?
Interstingly,
Filippo had just received his naturalization papers in July of that
same year (1969). If Filippo had a mental illness it could help
explain feeling suicidal, but I’d imagine that someone gaining that
milestone would be ecstatic. Was he not
happy about becoming a naturalized citizen? Considering it had been
done in July of that year, and just a few months later in september
he disappeared and went missing, did he perhaps have some sort of
mental illness we did not know about?
3.
Not that this is any of my business, but
where is he buried? There is no findagrave page, so I wonder if he
had a catholic burial since suicide is a sin in that religion.
4.
What were the type of people that he
worked with? Where did he work at to begin with, if he worked at all?
How much money did he make in order to buy a new Bug at the age of
23? What did his father do for work? Did filippo or his father buy
the car that he drove at his death? Assuming that filippo lived with
his parents as stated above that is.
5.
Is it possible that he was
running from someone? Or was he meeting someone there?
6.
Is it possible that the first part of
the story is true, where he pushed the car over, but then something
changed? Perhaps he was picked up hitch hiking and the person acted
like they were his friend, killing him at the end of the night or
something? If so, who could this person have been, and if the person
reportedly didn't seem to be tenerelli when signing into the motel,
how didn't bee greer notice? On top of that, did Bee see Filippo's
dead body? Could she determine that it was the same person that
signed into the front desk?
7.
Is it really possible that
filippo was so considerate to have placed towels and shot himself in
the head yet would barricade the door to essentially rot for a month?
8.
what was the point of buying a gun cleaning
kit if he was just going to shoot himself? Was it a formality at the
store maybe? Maybe he had to buy it with the gun?
9.
What happened to the rest of the alcohol if Filippo’s blood alcohol
proved that he didn’t drink it?
10.
Why isn’t there any report of any of the other tenants or employees
hearing a gunshot? If Filippo supposedly committed suicide in his
room, couldn’t there have been some sort of noise heard from the
shotgun?
11.
If the car was found AFTER Filippo’s death, where was it before the
mysterious person pushed it off of the cliff?
My
overall thoughts:
Personally,
I do not think that the Manson family had anything to do with
Filippo’s death. That may sound crazy, but the evidence that Tom
O’Neill presented in his book is quite weak, and even wrong at
times. For example, he stated that Bill Vance had a ‘magic vest’
with pubes from various people on it. That’s not true. It was
actually a vest that Charlie had, which no-one else was supposed to
wear (though you can see Sandra Good wearing it in the Manson 70’s
documentary), comprised of the hair from various members of the
Manson family. Besides, Death Valley is a big
place, and the areas that Filippo were supposedly at during his last
days are very far away from where the Manson gang were.
What
do I really think happened? Well, I do think that in some way Filippo
was murdered. In two ways. The first being that once he died, his
death was essentially covered up, and the second being that someone
really had it against him. Honestly, O’Neill
wrote all these things in his book about how it seems to add up that
the Manson family had something to do with it, when in reality the
picture couldn’t be any more obvious to me. He wrote about how the
police would clam up about talking about anything new, about knowing
the truth, and giving out any information. It seems to me that
Filippo was probably killed by the police themselves.
Halfway
through reading about him, I had the thought that perhaps Filippo was
a victim of racism. Keep in mind, this was back in 1969. People were
not as tolerant of others with different backgrounds like today. It’s
possible that someone hated him because he was Italian. . Because
he spoke with an accent. I do not know where
he worked, but if he had any sun exposure, it’s possible he could
have been quite tan even and mistaken for a darker race. Either
way, the situation screams of racism and a police cover up to me.
The
biggest indicator for me is that his gunshot wound is in the back of
the head. Whoever didn’t like him shot him, took his body, and
planted it there in the hotel room, coming in and out of the window.
The
method of murder is not even consistent with the Manson killings
either. Everyone in the Tate-LaBianca murders were stabbed in some
way. Even Gary Hinman. Even
Shorty Shea.
[SOURCES]
https://www.foxnews.com/us/another-manson-murder-debra-tate-victims-family-advocate-for-a-re-investigation-of-the-1969-suicide-of-young-man-in-california
‘Chaos’
by Tom O’Neill, and the subsequent facebook page for it.